The public is overwhelmingly shocked and outraged by the brutal murder of a young girl, calling for immediate and severe punishment for the perpetrator, and expressing deep concerns over children's safety and the inadequacies of the current juvenile justice system. Many comments stress the urgency for stricter laws, better policing, and a fundamental reassessment of societal values that contribute to such violent crimes.

Government of India

Hyderabad Police

Parents

Local Community

I think have police made him to do scene reconstruction. I dont think he could manage it if he is not the real one.

Livid_Piglet2653

He might have done it. But how come an under 18 yr old cannot be punishable if he/she is willing to do this kind of attacks? 
This rules need to modify. A 11yr old is developing softwares, winning national chess championships but when it comes to law they can escape even if he is mentally matured and will to do such evil acts??

PlanB_NotThere

That-Gap-8803

Not deporting shit stains like these leads to people hating all immigrants and the rise of fascism. We need to deal with this or we're all gonna go the way of Hungary and Slovakia because leftist and moderate politicians are too scared to discuss immigration honestly.

Kiljukotka

flufffyzebra

Get every single one fingerprinted, DNA taken and photograph


Have a Europe wide database and include the UK in that

iwaterboardheathens

They're just poor and traumatized 🥺

/s

shaftus-maximus

OneGladTurtle

I feel like I read this news every week lol

Total_Ad9973

Veso10

Not sure why everyone here is blaming the Left when Rightwing parties have been in charge of the Netherlands for 10+ years. The only way to manage this is to tighten EU borders, which means you actually need someone like Timmermans who understands how the EU works, how to make deals with countries, and therefore how to reduce migration. All the right do in the Netherlands is grand stand without effect, because in the end their popularity is fed by increased migration and they know it.

FuzzyYellow9046

"We need more moorish imigrants" I'm so tired of the European left. They are destroying our homes and comunities.

Gmatoshenriques

Lets do it like the US idiots do it with their weekly shooters... send out a prayer and hope it gets better.

xExerionx

We are all tired. It's time to invest ourselves politically or this will continue. 



Share on social networks, make videos, shorts, anything, invest yourself locally if you can. Anything is better then nothing. 

BobYloNO

[deleted]

He had to escape, into young white girls bodies

Few-Working794

Can someone explain to me why Halsema of all people had to take centrestage during the press conference? She has no authority over Abcoude and isn't an authority figure over immigration (thank god) either.

Betonkauwer

I don’t really get these news. Thousands of rapes and hundreds of murders happen in each country, but you only report about a select few… emphasizing random a factor like immigration status, not favorite football club or height or specific hobbies or wealth. How the fuck does the media decide which of the tens of thousands of crimes to report individually?

mordordoorodor

It’s a terrible tragedy, but luckily extremely rare over here. On average the crime rate among asylum seekers is lower than among the Dutch populatie. 

PS who left te door open and let all the rightwing nuts in?

No-Tomatillo3698

Honestly, I feel if it wouldn’t have become viral .. they wouldn’t have been arrested too :( 

Really hurts to see such dudes coming out and live with us

now watch this fade into non existence slowly . The accused will go away to UK or USA and live their best life

Rohit_BFire

bhenchod420

Why is nowhere that i see the name of the MLA whose son was charged's name mentioned? He should be named and shamed.

nocturnal_prince

Another case of Brock Turner, the rapist, "boys will be boys" nonsense

swansong92

Saw how this would play out weeks ago.

Now that people are outraging on other issues everyone will forget this.

Just 10 upvotes in over 24 hours. I remember this getting 100s of upvotes on the initial days. Damn we're fatigued.

pundidas

hopelesstaurusbitxch

It's still a bail.

The case is going fast track  so I guess we will see some justice.


They got 65 witnesses and they will testify in court 

But still it's india anything can happen here.

Rich priveleged kids from political families can rape and even kill your daughter, wife or sister but can't do anything about it 

Suck world

rehan_27

Suspicious-Egg-2648

That's horrifying that 4 men could collaborate to rape and murder 9 women. How does anyone get that depraved? Is there a name for serial killings by a group? Poor woman, her last moments must have been so horrific... I'm not sorry those men are dead.

zanylife

I'm not sorry they're dead. I doubt very much that they would have been punished appropriately under the law considering how women are always blamed for the horrors that men do to them. Also, it looks like there are three different names for her between what you wrote and your sources. I'm pretty sure her real name is visible, so if you didn't want to share it, you might want to remove that source.

CallidoraBlack

Absolutely horrific. Tbh street justice like this seems to be the only justice these days. The more I delve into true crime, the more I believe in the death penalty. Some people don't deserve to live, even in prison.

Ambitious-Yogurt23

&gt; Yes, the judicial &amp; legal system is over burdened beyond belief, yes it takes years, sometimes decades to see court cases through and yes conviction rates are not high in cases of sexual assault or murder. But still, extra judicial killings are perhaps not the solution

&gt; What are you thoughts? Was justice served?

As long as the legal system is failing by blaming women for being victims of male violence, and by allowing rapists and murderers to walk free, I don't see any moral issues with them being taken out by vigilantes.

Greggs_VSausageRoll

I lived and worked in places like this. I'm not saying at all that these men were innocent in this situation, but just highlighting that sometimes the suspects are just poor, uneducated people who are easy targets themselves for cops looking for a quick solution. The cops will dust them off (or they'll sell the suspects to the victims family and they'll do it), case closed.  The cops are sometimes the perpetrators themselves in these places, and they just hang it on whoever. The majority of the world, once you move outside of these little bubbles we live in of supposed freedom and fairness, is not fair at all, and justice is more than most can afford.

TimmehJ

Since true legal justice is so rare and fleeting, I believe this is the best justice the victims could ever get. It sounds like they were shot which is MUCH more humane and merciful than being kidnapped, gang raped, murdered, and torched, like they did to so many of their victims. They deserved worse.  

If street justice is what it takes to rid the world of these monsters and to protect everyone in society, then so be it. These were serial killers with significant evidence against them, and they raped and murdered multiple innocent victims who died horrible, agonizing deaths. The absence of these monsters makes the world a better place.

FTThrowAway123

So it’s not justice but it’s definitely fitting. In this specific incident if they had the correct 4 guys.

With solid evidence I don’t see any problem with eliminating them from society. The burden of proof should be extremely high though to avoid killing innocents. For that reason alone I wouldn’t be part of vigilante justice. I’m to afraid to get the wrong guys.

Naturopathy101

This reminds me of the Delhi bus case. I am glad those men are dead.

pergine

The only thing that concerns me about this is I hope they didn’t die quickly. They deserved to suffer in their last moments, just like poor Disha must have done. 

We recently had a very similar case in the UK, except it was only one guy. He planned out a premeditated abduction and rape and then burned the victim after. He got life without parole (which is very very rare here) but he’s being kept in isolation, so although I doubt that’s pleasant, he’s physically safe, getting three meals a day, free medical and dental care whenever he needs it, undoubtedly free psychiatric care too. Imo (and I know this is an unpopular opinion) but sometimes just being in jail isn’t enough. The perpetrators should be in constant pain and fear every moment of the rest of their lives. You forfeit your human rights the second you deprive someone else of theirs.

abstract-heart

True Justice was not served in this case it puzzles me as to why the suspects weren't handcuffed during the reconstruction of the crime as they should've been

My problem with the extra-judicial killings is that the family deserved to have this case heard in court, and the public NEEDS to have evidence of this happening all too often shoved in their faces every time it does happen. That would maybe begin to shift national discourse and public sentiment enough to affect policy.

Dang Rest In Peace poor girl…truly awful I can’t imagine the horror she went through. May they burn in hell.

danidee262019

Being from India, I know most about all of the cases you write about. But your writing is so good and well researched that is always worthwhile reading about these cases again.

Infinite-Sympathy-53

It looks like OP posted an AMP link. These should load faster, but AMP is controversial because of [concerns over privacy and the Open Web](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmputatorBot/comments/ehrq3z/why_did_i_build_amputatorbot).

Maybe check out **the canonical page** instead: **[https://mobile.twitter.com/priya_richi/status/1203985429604646912](https://mobile.twitter.com/priya_richi/status/1203985429604646912)**

*****

 ^(I'm a bot | )[^(Why &amp; About)](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmputatorBot/comments/ehrq3z/why_did_i_build_amputatorbot)^( | )[^(Summon: u/AmputatorBot)](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmputatorBot/comments/cchly3/you_can_now_summon_amputatorbot/)

AmputatorBot

This has me a little torn. On the one hand, I see the heavy handed way LE in the US treat people and am abhorred, yet on the other I too often see monsters like this not receiving proper justice. I know I should be against what happened here, but I can't make myself empathetic to them. 

As a side note, I feel rape is treated far too leniently and genuinely believe it is the most heinous crime. Rapists should receive life sentences, IMHO, but I also wonder if that would entice rapists to murder more often? Rapists are the lowest form of life and to murder that poor woman is plain inhuman. They can rot in hell.

Macr0Penis

'Encounter killings' are common in some places, in the United States they are just getting started.

After a killing like that the public should examine the original evidence carefully to make sure the killing was not to cover something else up.

Any killing that is justified 100% at the time of the crime becomes less justified as time passes.

So if the victim had been able to kill the attackers it would have been 100% justified, but as time passes less so.

Killing prisoners is never justified, no matter what they have done.

The fact that the police are hired specifically to arrest criminals, in other words they serve a civilizing function in a melting pot of mixed clans, makes it problematic when they kill people instead of arresting them.

That kind of justice is only applied to 'other' clans. The police officers involved would not use that tactic on their own clan.

AddendumActive864

Within the past month:

After perusing the CCTV footage, the \[The Supreme Court-appointed inquiry commission\] said that they could not see any visuals of the victim being carried by the accused in the \[CCTV\] clips shown. [Source](https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/hyderabad/panel-examines-cctv-footage-of-crime-scene/articleshow/87788349.cms)

AndrewSB49

Hi. If you're thinking why they weren't handcuffed is because no handcuffs are used by police. 

Handcuffs have been deemed against human rights and are banned. 

Instead of handcuffs [police just hold hands of perpetrator](https://i.redd.it/0mgpwhexlmo11.jpg)

1NbSHXj3

I remember this case along with Nirbhaya and Asifa. To some extent I am happy that they are dead but I can’t help but feel the Indian judicial system needs more improvement regarding this kind of crimes. I also wonder if it would have been dragged on like the Nirbhaya case or completely forgotten after some time like Asifa’s case

Complex-Historical

I personally can’t stand it when someone discusses a topic like this and then op throws their two cents in about vigilante justice being wrong- especially in a country where judicial justice is almost nonexistent. Does that self righteousness serve the family of the victim in any way?

sheepsclothingiswool

Very disturbing to read. 😔
   
&gt; The three minor accused, who have been detained, have told police that they disposed of the girl's body in an irrigation canal in Muchumarri. The girl's body has not been recovered yet. 
   
Worse than evil. I hope they are not treated as minors and jailed for life.

RealKreideprinz

A snooping dog found them ....... victim was in class three..... criminals were in class 7....

Hot_Broccoli3501

The fact that three 12 YEAR OLD CHILDREN have done this vile thing says how f'ed up our gen is..

I_love_my_life80

I know our country is severely lacking in educating men on how to treat women properly...but I don't know how education, even from a young age, would have prevented this. This is just pure evil...

Witcher94

Your post title is misleading, seniors sound like they are adults, they are actually 12 and 13 years kids.

It's disgusting to read how nasty humans have become.. but still we hide ourselves under the robe of being cultured

Convicts are minors, our shithole laws will put them in juvenile home for some time and then they'd be out again to commit crime as adults.  

*Under the Powers of Criminal Courts (Sentencing) Act, 2000, a person below 18 convicted of a serious offence may be sentenced to a period not exceeding the maximum term of imprisonment for adults. This includes a life sentence as well. The young offenders are kept in separate institutions and not jails*

Competitive-Fall-343

marinluv

Most-Bandicoot645

If 12 yo are rape-murdering 8 yo a lot of things went wrong to let things get to this. On top of an investigation, some study should be to find out what factors led to this or increase these incidents.

What the actual fuck. They’ll all go to juvie prison &amp; get off when they turn 18 :(

turtledoveangel_3

The destruction of innocence. We have failed as a society, we failed the girl child and we are failing to educate our boys. There needs to be better education and censorship. At 13 we didn’t know what sex was and these morons have the depravity to assault another human being. A child. 
This is a sick day.

Silly-Amoeba7605

Let’s see the path Judiciary takes this time….although no hope as such

avenger1840

I’m no longer concerned of going to hell. We’re living in one!

OrekiHoutarou3

Cold_Ear5727

Some countries brought down the punishable age(age of criminal responsibility ) to 12.  

Some even have 7.  


As a former 12yo, I knew many things were wrong.

DukeOfLongKnifes

The law for juveniles has to be changed and they have to treat such heinous crimes under as adult crimes 
These boys are evil and there is no way that they are minors in their thought feelings and deeds 
8 year old is a baby what a torture she has undergone hope these boys rot on this earth

Prestigious-Play-841

Why would you want to raise a family in India after knowing such things are regular things and not once in a blue moon?!

Jepbar_Halmyradov

12 &amp; 13 years old raping...

and killing...

I am speechless.

The system needs to change. Immediately. Women in India needs more protection. 

The fact that the accused can get away somehow someway or with minimum sentences, grooms a future rapists.

DesperateChest

School kids do all kind of stupid things … but not this … this is just pure evil … no amount of rehabilitation will change them or absolve of their sins

Dude. Wtf is this? Straight death penalty for all of them. No prison sentence

Grey_shark

Beech raste mein fasi dena cahiye , ek example set hona mangta hai lekin saala gov mein he half se zada rapist pade hai ! Hang till death is the only solution.

MERU9616

but if i say India has a rape culture problem I'd be called a feminazi and anti-national.


i weep for the women of our country who have barely any power against these creatures. she was just a child. these demons don't see girls has humans. 


i don't care if they're 13. if they can rape, they deserve to be hanged and their remains fed to pigs.

Jaehyunspout

When children get there sex education from phone this will happen again and again.

We need a proper sex education system implementation for school, college students and for there guardians.

Without that next generation will be like animals who can kill anyone if they were stopped from fulfilling there lust regardless of age.

-yato_gami-

Dagger_LFC

Execute this mfs.
A teenager will have urges but how can they lack even an ounce of empathy for the poor baby girl !!

More than girls boys should be taught about controlling their lust by their parents (atleast the father).

Moral science should be more strictfully taught in schools

Instagram reels promoting sexual activeness in kids. I have a 10 year old nephew who is exposed to vulgarity in a way we were never even aware of. When I was 10 year old even I was aware of cuss words and nudity due to wwe shows and laser tags but this kids have so much stimulation via internet nowadays that few bad apples like these fuckers are gona act out.

ShameCalm9130

I know these fuckers will be left free once they turn 18. The punishment of rape should be same for all.  Hang them at all costs. 

They killed her. They always knew their act was a crime. This scoundrels thought they could get away by killing her. Should be punished just like any adult.

UT849

&gt; A sniffer dog led police to the three minor boys. Two of them are Class 6 students, aged 12, and one is in Class 7 and is 13. All three are students of the same school to which the girl went. During questioning, the boys admitted to raping and murdering the girl, police have said

The laws have to change to give these guys life sentence.

GovtOfficer420

puddi_tat

This what happens if we focus on religion more than morals and education. I know people will downvote for saying this but we should educate the young on morals, humanity, righteousness, not religion. They should know the difference between right and wrong. This is just bad parenting plus easy and unguided access to internet

karthik777777

Wtf? School seniors? The court should hang them and send their teachers and parents  in the jail too, for not teaching their kids how to live in this world. Animals.

JohanHex96

Where is that duffer Pawan Kalyan? He was so indignant about Sugali Preethi, made remake of Pink in Telugu and is now the deputy CM and not a single word.

krakends

Ye kya dekhna pad raha hain bc. Jio fucked this country

Original-Nobody2596

what fucking hell ! class 3 kid gang raped by class 7 kids !

hikes_likes

_BruH_MoMent69

This is why I say that laws in India should sometimes be just like Saudi Arabia or Singapore. Once a fair trial is conducted, the punishment in those countries is so brutal that nobody else would dare repeat the crime.

For example, no tourist would dare to litter in Singapore. And nobody dares to carry drugs or commit theft in Saudi Arabia

smartharty7

I am literally shaking after going through the article.
I recently became a parent and have a 15 months old daughter,

I can’t comprehend the level of sadness I am going through right now just by thinking about the parents of the little soul.

soulz_pitrified

A 14-year-old boy has been arrested for the murder of a 10-year-old girl in a panicked attempt to steal a cricket bat from her house.

Teenage Crime in Hyderabad: Murder of 10-Year-Old Girl

Why This Matters

Public Sentiment Summary

Highlighted Comments

Parties Involved

What the people want